MLB

Sonny Gray Is 37 and the Twins Just Gave Him $55 Million. It Is Still the Right Move.

The Minnesota Twins announced Wednesday that Sonny Gray is coming back, and the reported price is two years and $55 million. Jon Heyman had the figure first. Jeff Passan reported that Gray holds an opt-out after the 2027 season, which means year two belongs to the pitcher and not to the club.

Gray turned 37 on November 7. He is about to pitch his age-37 and age-38 seasons at roughly $27.5 million a year, with the right to walk after one of them. On paper that is how front offices get themselves in trouble.

Minnesota should have signed it anyway. It did.

He Just Had the Best Season of His Career

Gray went 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA across 169 innings for the Boston Red Sox in 2026. He struck out 149, walked 46, carried a 1.148 WHIP and a 3.47 FIP, and held hitters to a .236 average over 29 starts. He tied for the major league lead in wins, led the American League in winning percentage at .783, and finished fifth in Cy Young voting.

That 2.72 is the lowest full-season ERA he has ever posted. Thirty-seven-year-old starters are supposed to be managing decline, not setting personal bests. The ones who pull it off tend to do it on command and sequencing rather than velocity, which is exactly the kind of pitcher Gray has become.

This Is a Reunion, Not a Gamble on a Stranger

Gray pitched for the Twins in 2022 and 2023 and was very good in both seasons: 16-13 with a 2.90 ERA over 303.2 innings, 300 strikeouts and a 1.14 WHIP in 56 starts. He made the 2023 All-Star team in Minnesota and finished second in American League Cy Young voting that year behind Gerrit Cole.

He left after that season for three years and $75 million with St. Louis, pitched to a 4.28 ERA over 180.2 innings in 2025, and was traded to Boston that November along with cash for Richard Fitts, Brandon Clarke and Patrick Galle. Boston paid a $10 million buyout rather than pick up a $30 million mutual option, which is how he reached the market.

The Rotation Needed It More Than the Payroll Could Afford It

The Twins finished 77-85 and third in the AL Central. Their rotation behind Joe Ryan is thin: Pablo Lopez missed all of 2026 after February Tommy John surgery, and Taj Bradley is the other arm anyone would call a lock. Minnesota opened 2026 just north of $100 million in payroll and finished 22nd in the sport.

Owner Tom Pohlad said earlier this offseason that “a $100 million payroll or anything close to that is not sufficient to be consistently competitive” and that making the playoffs “isn’t a hope, it’s the expectation.” Those comments came before this signing rather than in response to it. They still read like a promise the club has now partly kept, a year after a nine-deal 2025 deadline sell-off that shipped out Jhoan Duran, Griffin Jax, Louis Varland, Carlos Correa and Harrison Bader.

The Calendar Is the Other Half of This

The collective bargaining agreement expires December 1 at 11:59 p.m. ET, a lockout is widely expected, and the Winter Meetings are expected to be canceled. Nobody has reported that Gray signed early because of that deadline, so nobody should claim he did. What is true is that his $55 million is the second-largest free agent deal of this offseason behind Jake Bauers at four years and $58 million with Boston, and the largest handed to a pitcher.

The Twins put it best on their own account: “Skies are Gray but things are looking Sonny! Welcome back, Sonny Gray!” Two years for a 37-year-old coming off a career season is a risk. Doing nothing with Ryan in his prime and Lopez returning from surgery would have been the bigger one.

Carlos Garcia

A longtime sports reporter, Carlos Garcia has written about some of the biggest and most notable athletic events of the last 5 years. He has been credentialed to cover MLS, NBA and MLB games all over the United States. His work has been published on Fox Sports, Bleacher Report, AOL and the Washington Post.
Back to top button