MLB

Royce Lewis Demoted to Triple-A by Twins as Former No. 1 Pick Hits Rock Bottom in 2026

Royce Lewis is in Triple-A. Read that sentence again. The first overall pick of the 2017 MLB Draft was optioned by the Twins to St. Paul on Tuesday, the first time he has played in the minors on anything other than a rehab assignment since 2022.

The numbers explain the move. Lewis is hitting .163 this season. His OPS is .539, which is closer to a pitcher’s batting line than a third baseman’s. His OPS has dropped every year since 2023, falling from .921 to .747 to .671 and now to its current floor. The Twins ran out of patience.

“I want to give him a mental breather across the river and a chance to reset,” Twins GM Jeremy Zoll said. “Get him going. Get that confidence back.” That is the polite version. The real version is that Lewis was not producing, the Twins are out of the wild card race already, and they could not justify burning at-bats on a struggling former top prospect any longer.

Lewis was supposed to be the cornerstone of this Twins core. He was the No. 1 pick. He was the playoff hero in 2023 when he hit four homers in his first four postseason games. He was the future face of the franchise. Now he is in the minors trying to find a swing he lost almost two years ago.

The injury history is part of the story. Lewis tore his ACL twice in the minors and has had multiple oblique strains and hamstring issues since reaching the majors. He has never played more than 100 games in a season. Every time he gets healthy, the bat takes weeks to come around. This year it never did.

The bigger problem is mechanical. Lewis has been chasing pitches outside the zone at a career-worst rate. His swing path has gotten longer. His exit velocities are down across the board. None of that is the result of bad luck. It is a hitter who has lost his timing and cannot find it under big-league pressure.

Triple-A St. Paul is the right place for him to work it out. Lower stakes. Familiar coaches. Quality pitching but not the daily grind of major-league at-bats. He can play every day, simplify his approach, and try to remember what made him a generational hitting prospect in the first place.

The Twins are in a brutal spot too. Carlos Correa is on the IL again. Byron Buxton is on the IL again. The starting pitching has been a mess. Pablo Lopez was their ace, and now Joe Ryan is fighting for that spot. Minnesota is 18-28 entering Wednesday and looking like a clear seller at the trade deadline.

If Lewis can figure it out in St. Paul, the Twins have a reset they did not see coming. If he cannot, his trade value is now zero, and Minnesota is stuck eating the development cost of a former No. 1 pick who never delivered on the promise.

What makes this story sad is that Lewis is only 26. He has time to fix this. Most top prospects who flame out do it in their first few years. Lewis already had two All-Star-caliber seasons in the bag. He has shown what he can be when healthy and confident. The Twins are not giving up on him. They are pressing pause.

Ryan Jeffers also went on the IL on Tuesday with a fractured hand. The Twins designated Daniel Topa for assignment. This is the worst week the franchise has had in a long time, and it lined up perfectly with a Royce Lewis demotion that nobody wanted to make.

The Twins built around him. Now they have to find out if he can rebuild himself in time to matter.

Carlos Garcia

A longtime sports reporter, Carlos Garcia has written about some of the biggest and most notable athletic events of the last 5 years. He has been credentialed to cover MLS, NBA and MLB games all over the United States. His work has been published on Fox Sports, Bleacher Report, AOL and the Washington Post.
Back to top button